Light Sleeper - Late Night Writings On Cinema
       
Edison: The Invention of the Movies
Reviewed by Aaron W. Graham

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aaron W. Graham, 21, is a cinephile based in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. In addition to his writings on film, he has written several screenplays. His journal can be found here: http://awcgfilmlog.blogspot.com/
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Directors (as their work appears chronologically): W.K.L. Dickson, William Heise, Alfred Clark, James H. White, Frederick Blechynden, William Paley, J. Stuart Blackton, Albert E. Smith, Thomas Krahan, Robert K. Bonine, Edwin S. Porter, George S. Fleming, James Blair Smith, Alfred C. Abadie, Arthur White, N. Dushane Cloward, Wallace McCutcheon, J. Searle Dawley, Ashley Miller, Oscar C. Apfel, C. Jay Williams, Carlton King, Charles M. Seay, Charles J. Brabin, Harold M. Shaw, Will Louis, Edward C. Taylor, Alan Crosland
Country: USA
Years of Original Release: 1891-1918
Running times: 20 seconds to 85 minutes (individual films); 910 minutes (entire set)
Discs: Four
 

Contrary to what the title of this set may suggest, Thomas Alva Edison never directed a film for the company he created, much preferring the mechanical side of the business that went into developing the tools needed to actually make films. Through a series of ground-breaking inventions, including the first motion picture camera (initially horizontal-fed), a viewing machine, equipment for printing and sprocket punching, the first projector, and even a rough experiment that resulted in the first synchronized sound film (included on disc one), Edison and his associates financed and devised the art-form that we now commonly refer to as Cinema. Kino’s 4-DVD set encompasses the entire breadth of this studio’s output, from the rough camera tests of 1889 to the last feature length film that the studio released in 1918. Assembled and curated by Steven Higgins, Department of Film at The Museum of Modern Art (MoMa) and Charles Musser, Professor of Film and American Studies at Yale University, Edison: The Invention of the Movies is a fascinating time capsule of the rise and fall of what is generally considered to be the very first motion picture company.

With the option of being able to play the films along with a series of interviews from the likes of Higgins, Musser, and other noteworthy authors and professors, or to watch the films separately, disc one contains the primitive undertakings that first resulted in moving pictures. Monkeyshines, No. 1 (1889-90) and Monkeyshines, No. 2 (1889-90) both begin and end with flickering ghost-like images of a figure that only last for twenty seconds apiece. The next film, Dickson Greeting (1891), is the earliest concrete representation of actual moving people on film that’s wholly perceivable. It is only fitting that the person captured on these frames would also happen to be the very first film director. William Kennedy-Laurie Dickson (1860-1935) was an associate of Edison’s that long-harbored the dream of making photographs move. He was crucial for both the development of the emulsion process and the size of the 35mm wide frame, which is still being used today. He would leave the Edison Co. in 1895 and form the rival American Mutoscope and Biograph.

These aforementioned works were never intended for public viewing, but the next several dozen films that appear on the disc were produced upon the invention of the peephole kinetograph. This was a device in which the customer would dispense of a nickel and watch an image move for the length of fifty feet of film stock. These works would later be deemed ‘Actuality’ films because of the uncomplicated way they attempted to capture reality. A famous example would be the Edison Kinetoscopic Record of a Sneeze, January 7, 1894 (18940, which featured an Edison employee, Fred Ott, doing just that. Almost all of the subjects captured in this period (1892-1900) were either Coney Island attractions (Annabelle Butterfly Dance [1894]), vanilla acts of sex (The John C. Rice-May Irwin Kiss [1895]) or violence (Corbett and Courtney Before the Kinetograph [1894]), elementary tableaus of beautiful scenery (American Falls from Above, American Side [1896]), blazing fires (A Morning Alarm [1896]), fast-moving trains (Black Diamond Express, No. 1 [1896]), the Boer War (Capture at Boar Battery by British [1898]), or, before their departure for a European tour, acts from "Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show" (Annie Oakley [1894]). It is undetermined to what extent both Dickson and William Heise divided the chores in directing these early works, though it is widely believed that Heise operated the camera. Indeed, the term "filmmaker" is loosely used in regards to the Edison movies until the early 1900’s, when the roles of who did what are more discernable. There were very few fiction films within this time frame and the few that were (The Lone Fisherman [1896]; A Wringing Good Joke [1899]) are either uninvolving scenes from popular stage plays (the former) or remakes of popular hits from other companies like Biograph (the latter). The majority of the company’s output was filmed inside "Black Maria", Edison’s studio built solely for the reason of making motion pictures. And almost entirely throughout these short works, the camera stays at a fixed position in an establishing shot (though there are deviants such as The John C. Rice-May Irwin Kiss [1895] which takes place entirely in an intimate medium close-up).

After almost selling the Edison Manufacturing Company in 1900, Edison then built a studio in New York and the films begin to get longer and more captivating. The first projectors are introduced and Edwin S. Porter, a former exhibiter, begins to direct more accomplished films for the company. Burlesque Suicide, No. 2 (1902) takes place entirely in a medium-shot and features a mustached, middle-aged gentleman playfully contemplating suicide with the use of a handgun being pointed to his temple out-of-frame. At the film’s close, he places the gun on the table and takes a drink. Pan-American Exposition At Night (1901), though classified as an "Actuality" film, is noteworthy for the inventive early use of the pan/tilt and the utilization of a dissolve from day to night. Such methods of film grammar are taken for granted nowadays but back then such ingenuity was surely something to marvel at.

Inspired by Méliès’ Cinderella (1899) and Blue Beard (1902), Edison & Co. made the nearly ten-minute, ten-shot Jack and the Beanstalk in 1902 with painted backdrops helping to illustrate the fantasy. The Life of an American Fireman (1903) is considered to be, along with The Great Train Robbery (also 1903), a supreme early achievement in film narrative. The former relies on showing temporal overlaps from different perspectives, instead of intercutting for suspense, at nearly every transition in order to not confuse the then neophyte viewer. The latter is presented in a gorgeous hand-tinted print that helps to express how truly important it is in the history of cinema, especially to those only familiar with it through black-and-white transfers. The bandit facing the camera to hold-up the audience in the film’s final seconds has not lost its punch in the any of the ensuing one-hundred-years plus since its premiere.

Disc two covers the company between the years of 1904 and 1907, from several short-minute, light-hearted comedies like How a French Nobleman Got a Wife Through the New York Herald Personal Columns (1904), which illustrates Porter’s fascination with the chase, to longer, more melodramatic fair like The Ex-Convict (1904) and The Klepto-Maniac (1905), the latter being a treatise on the discriminations between the rich and poor in the justice system. Another highlight is Edwin S. Porter’s The Little Train Robbery (1905), a spoof of his blockbuster with children in the all of the lead roles. Kino, MoMa, and the Library of Congress have chosen to include some of the more racist works for historical purposes, such as The White Caps (1905) and The Watermelon Patch (1905), both of which are admittedly more playful about stereotypes than that of rival company Biograph. The Dream of a Rarebit Fiend (1906) is probably one of Porter’s most invigorating works and certainly his most accomplished in technical aspects. Based on Winsor McKay’s comic-strip "Little Nemo in Slumberland" and a Pathe film entitled Rave a la Lune (Gaston Velle, 1905), the story opens with a young gentleman feasting on rarebit and having a bit too much to drink. After exiting the restaurant, he attempts to balance himself on a lamppost as the camera recording the event seemingly swings wildly out of control. In the next scene, the gentleman has found his way home and readies himself for bed. We are then transported inside his dream and watch as he holds onto his bed for dear life (obviously appropriated from the famous image in McCay’s strip). Porter takes out all the stops and uses split-screen, stop-motion, and superimpositions to highlight different areas of his flight over New York. In the last sequence, the man crashes through his building’s floor and, after a dissolve, finally wakes up in bed. The disc closes with The "Teddy" Bears (1907), a take-off on "Goldilocks and the Three Bears" mixed with an incident involving Theodore Roosevelt and his refusal to shoot a baby cub. Porter showcases an early use of POV as Goldilocks looks through a keyhole to see the three bears dancing (captured through the means of stop-motion).

Disc three includes an early appearance of D.W. Griffith as a father attempting to rescue his captured baby from an eagle in Rescued From an Eagle’s Nest (1908). Fireside Reminiscences (1908) is told in three simple set-ups. Set-up #1: a husband discovers his wife in the arms of another man and immediately leaves without discovering that it was actually her brother. Set-up #2: after finishing dinner, the husband sits next to a fireplace where the events that came after what happened in set-up #1 are projected as super-impositions into the fireplace representing his subjective thought. Set-up #3: back to the same camera placement as #1, as the wife and husband are reunited with their child acting as catalyst.

The works of Edwin S. Porter, which began near the end of disc one and encompass disc two entirely, begin to taper off in the middle of the third disc. He became a studio head for the Edison Manufacturing Co. for a short period in January 1909 but never directed a film again. Meanwhile, Edison’s business began to pick up in the years of 1911 and 1912 with one-reel westerns, melodramas and comedies representing most of their product. The Passer-By (Oscar C. Apfel, 1912) is a somber tale about lost love but it also features an exhilarating early use of a push-in on the lead as he begins to tell his hard luck tale, pushing back out once again after a dissolve on his now much younger face.

Disc four closes with the only feature-length film included in the set, 1918’s The Unbeliever (1918), directed by the man who would later make The Jazz Singer (1927), Alan Crosland. Based on the novelette "Three Things" by Mary Raymond Shipman Andrews, The Unbeliever tells the tale of Philip Landicut (Raymond McKee), a rich boy from Long Island who goes off to war and learns how to respect the "lower classes", many of which become his friends. Philip finds God on the battlefront as he collapses in a Christ-like pose after being wounded. He wakes up in a hospital bed and questions the nurse as to the age of the boy in the bed next to his. As the intertitle explicitly tells us, Philip expresses empathy for this injured young man, but only until he sees the man cry out in pain in his native tongue -- he’s a German. Despite being part of a propagandist series of films (Griffith’s Hearts and the World [1918]; William Nigh’s My Four Years in Germany [1918]; Allen Holubar’s The Heart of Humanity [1918]), a scene such as this leads one to think that the filmmakers involved didn’t necessarily think in black and white. Erich Von Stroheim is also featured as a detestable German officer who murders women and children without a moment’s notice. Apparently, Von Stroheim was quite proud of his performance here as it’s mentioned in one of the supplemental interviews that he took the woman he was to later marry to see it during one of their first dates. He had already been directing second-unit at the time, for Douglas Fairbanks, but was fired at the outset of World War I simply because of the German connotations of his name. Crosland’s direction breaks conventionality and theatricality in such scenes as the one in which Philip returns home after his stay at the infirmary. Crosland has it so that both Philip and his mother stare straight into the camera and directly at us, as the intertitles tell us just how far Philip has come in his journey.

The writing was on the wall much earlier in the early 1910’s when Edison had decided to spend most of his time and money working on such experimental notions as a home-theater projector and films with synchronized sound. He finally sold his company lock, stock and barrel in 1918. The rights, equipment, the name, almost everything went in the deal. Many of the scientists, engineers, and filmmakers involved with his studio were considered fossils by that time; they had already made their grand achievements. Nonetheless, their contribution in these thirty years took the industry from its initial conception to the blossoming of feature length films by the time of its closing.

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Copyright Aaron W. Graham 2005. No part of this article may be reprinted without permission of the author.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

To buy this film from Kino International click here