Light Sleeper - Late Night Writings On Cinema
       
Out of his Depp
By Bill Krohn
 
 

What is Jack Sparrow's problem? The former captain of the Black Pearl, scourge of the Seven Seas, seems rather like a sparrow hinself at times, with his bobbing head and fluttering hands. But birds don't wear black eyeshadow and make goo-goo eyes at their interlocuters while tilting their heads, and neither do pirates. And while we're on the subject, what's with the sensuously pursed lips and the Liverpudlian lisp? By way of explanation, Jack tells one credulous listener that his brains fried after his crew, led by his treacherous first mate Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush), stranded him on an atoll while they sailed off in search of a legendary cache of Aztec gold. But that story is as open to question as everything else Jack says, except for the part about the mutineers and the treasure, which turned out to be cursed.

The truth: Jack Sparrow is the latest eccentric characterization by Johnny Depp, the former teen idol who has become America's foremost comic actor since Marlon Brando, and his role model this time is his pal Keith Richards, the mad guitarist of Rolling Stones, Inc. In the hands of the wonderfully talented Mr. Depp, Sparrow somehow manages to combine Zorro's derring-do with the uber-twee body language of his foppish alter ego, Don Diego, and whether you buy that or not, you can't take your eyes off the screen when he is on it. This is a big help during the first act of Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl, which threatens to be just a straight-ahead pirate picture, dumbed-down by hordes of character actors cranking out lame comic relief like galley slaves. Afterwards, when the ghastly nature of the curse that has befallen the mutineers is made known and the special effects kick in, one senses the star's relief at not having to carry the rest of the picture by himself.

Produced by Jerry Bruckheimer and directed by Gore Verbinski, whose contribution is anyone's guess, Pirates of the Caribbean is the first movie based on a amusement-park ride -- one that certainly deserves its perennial popularity with visitors to the Walt Disney Company's flagship theme-park. If the picture works -- and why shouldn't it? -- we may be in for more. It's a Small World: The Movie, perhaps? Let's see: evil aliens dunk Earth in a bath of unknown radioactivity that transforms the inhabitants into ethnically and culturally correct cuddle-toys. But a pair of Ken and Barbie lookalikes (voiced by Edward Norton and Renée Zellweger) rally the doll-humans to put their differences aside and repel the invaders. Up comes the hauntingly familiar theme song, orchestrated for the big screen by Danny Elfman. So much for overpopulation...

Not all the news about Pirates of the Caribbean is good. Kiera Knightley and Orlando Bloom supply his-and-hers eye-candy and little else as characters who fell in love as children and haven't evolved much since. Seeing Jonathan Pryce squandered on the role of doting dad makes one almost nostalgic for those Lexus commercials. And the dumb gags enacted by sundry pirates, drunks and soldiers of the Empire strip from the venerable profession of Fool whatever laurels still clung to it, and trample them in the mire. As the Seventh Art sails into its second century, it sometimes appears that there is nothing left for it to do but imitate past triumphs. If so, the artists would be well advised to choose their models carefully, as Mr. Depp has done, and Mr. Rush has not. After a few promising flourishes at really playing the flamboyant Barbossa, he settles for imitating Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter, a role that has long since turned to ashes in the mouth of the actor who created it and is forced to keep repeating it. Mr. Rush having no such excuse, when he shouts during the climactic duel that he and Mr. Depp are "two immortals in a fight to the death" one is tempted to shout back, "Make that one immortal, Matey!" In any event, as Mr. Depp proves again here, one immortal is sometimes enough.

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Copyright Bill Krohn 2005. No part of this article may be reprinted without permission of the author.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------